Be warned that I am airing my very frustrated thoughts and am not in the mood to argue with any Trumpians right now. I’m turning comments off. Keep on scrollin’ if he’s your jam.
July 3rd: At a patriotic gathering beneath a monument carved on Native American tribe’s sacred space that we stole because gold was found there, Trump complains that teachers “indoctrinate” today’s youth and that schools teach “absolute allegiance” to “a new far-left fascism.”
(He has a very low reading comprehension level, paid people to do his homework and, I guarantee, has never helped his own children with homework so is overall unlikely to know what is ACTUALLY taught in schools. Also look at his gross gaudy golden house [images & hilarious captions from https://www.curbly.com/trump-is-a-living-mcmansion].)
As a teacher–one who teaches 11th grade American Literature, no less!–I am directly offended by his accusations. Schools are not for brainwashing. We teach critical thinking, literary analysis, close reading, expanded vocabulary skills, argumentative strategies, problem-solving, technological competency, clear and concise writing, judgment of reliable sources, narrative expression, public speaking readiness, appreciation of poetry, and MORE. We even study the Declaration of Independence (noting significant diction choices and edits from the rough to final draft, like how many of the founding fathers forced the deletion of any mention of slavery… because that “all men are created equal” thing meant, in their minds, land-owning white males) and the Constitution. We look chronologically at the writings of Americans and see how this country has never been perfect, and that those who speak up to point out (and protest) the flaws have assisted in its improvement, as we must continue to do now and forever. Thanks to school, students grow more empowered each year to add to that constructive criticism and change.
July 6th: Trump tweets that “SCHOOLS MUST OPEN IN THE FALL!!!”
He and his government have done very little to curb the pandemic here, which is why our citizens are currently not welcome to travel to a (rapidly growing) list of other countries. Therefore schools are not ready to open in a manner that will be safe for students, faculty, staff, subs, or any of the family/people/etc. who interact with them. Is it bad for student mental health, those who need meals or to escape abuse, etc.? Yes. That breaks my heart. (I have a lot of empathy. I doubt 45 could even spell empathy.)
But death, or even the chronic illnesses* that COVID-19 has been developing in many of the “survivors,” is worse. (Also, hold up: the goal of schools is education. That we have had to provide safety, food, social welfare… kinda sounds like something the government should be on top of? But what do I know, we just have a government that is supposed to “establish Justice, ensure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity,” filled with unqualified Trump children and a swamp of businessmen with conflicting interests, plus an education system led by Betsy DeVos who owns 10 yachts, is the daughter of a billionaire, went to private school, and thinks we need guns in school in case of grizzly bears. Don’t worry guys, grizzlies are scarier than COVID-19 or school shooters!)
July 8th: Trump tweets that “In Germany, Denmark, Norway, Sweden and many other countries, SCHOOLS ARE OPEN WITH NO PROBLEMS. The Dems think it would be bad for them politically if U.S. schools open before the November Election, but it is important for the children & families. May cut off funding if not open!”
Brian Klaas (Twitter @ brian klaas) notes that the new cases of COVID-19 yesterday (July 7th) in the US were 55,442. Scaling up the numbers to account for their smaller populations, the new cases in the other countries were equivalent to:
Germany 1,183; Denmark 570; Norway 676; and Sweden 1,835.
Other countries got to open schools because they listened to scientists instead of politicians. Trump is making this a narcissistic political battle when the facts are: IT IS NOT SAFE. It is not safe because of his choices and the selfish “individualism” of those [shamefully majority white Christian people] who think common sense/respect like mask-wearing is tyranny and oppression.
Tangent: note that Trump is desperate for reelection not because he wants to lead the country but because it buys him time to avoid prosecution for his various crimes… plus the NARCISSIST THING. Tangential tangent 2: Jeff and I just watched the entire John Adams miniseries. The burden of responsibility the first presidents took on, their wisdom and humility and skills… what a depressing contrast today makes!!!
So.
A reasonable conclusion from all this?
Trump is HOPING TEACHERS DIE.
The more educated someone is, the less likely they are to vote for him. He counts teachers as his enemy.
Another goal of his current attack on health insurance could be awareness of the cost upcoming chronic illnesses will have in healthcare. “America first” to him has always, always meant money (business and economy) first. Not people. Not lives.
Remember “The love of money is the root of all evil.” Then go read Psalm 109 for some more fun.
There.
Of course I want to teach. (I’m sure not in it for the money, teenage sass, and stress!) I flippin’ read & annotated this book for “fun” last month. I want to impact students, teach them to wield words with clarity and power, help them love literature, be a positive energy in their lives, and diminish the stupidity in the world.
But I don’t think any of us have to teach them in person during a global pandemic to achieve that.
I do not think it wise to risk my life and others’ when there is little to no guarantee that we will be supplied with what we need to decrease the risk. Consider how insane this all is: if one student develops COVID-19, then all the students and teachers they interact with in a day will have to quarantine (about 180 people), plus any subs or admin they interacted with (like if they have a younger sibling at another school–there’s another group of 30+ people!). We’ll be doing online school anyway! But now there will be germs festering in teachers and grandparents and everyone thanks to poor ventilation and imperfect hygiene. And we won’t have had time to adequately prepare for the best online education possible.
I volunteered to educate students, not regularly face the possibility of active shooters (remember that Trump is a draft dodger and hid in a bunker even though he claimed he’d “run in” to a school shooting event “even if [he] didn’t have a weapon”) or sacrifice myself on the front lines of a killer coronavirus (funny how 45 requires those who interact with him to take tests regularly and is dumb enough to think that slowing testing would slow the virus itself…).
We can all handle one more year of online schooling. If we all do better and acquire some true leadership, we can even bring that down to one semester of online schooling! Is it perfect? No. But it’s what we need while a pandemic is out of control here.
I can already predict the people who might have read this who will be angry with me: the same white, Christian relatives who post videos from Ben Shapiro, Prager U, Candace Owens, and InfoWars. (disclosure, I’m white and Christian too, and I even used to be Republican until they went off the g.d. rails.) I invite those people to come back and take my 11th grade English class. And if you want a conspiracy theory… how about Trump being Revelation’s beast? 🙃